The Jewish left is facing a complex dilemma as the right gains ground in the fight against antisemitism. Rabbi Charley Baginsky, a prominent figure in Progressive Judaism, found herself on the receiving end of boos at a recent rally, highlighting the growing tensions within the community. This incident reflects a broader sentiment among liberal and left-wing British Jews who feel isolated as right-wing figures take the lead in condemning antisemitism and defending Israel.
The article delves into the multifaceted nature of this issue, exploring the differing perspectives within the Jewish community. Some argue that antisemitism can only be effectively confronted through broad alliances with other minority communities and anti-racist movements. However, others express suspicion towards these spaces, believing that antisemitism has been minimized or tolerated within them. The research into British Jews' voting preferences reveals a shift, with support for the Greens surpassing that of Reform in 2025.
The text also examines the political landscape, noting the right's growing influence and the left's fading trust. Raphi Bloom, from the Jewish Representative Council, highlights the historical bond between Labour and Jewish values of social responsibility, but acknowledges the erosion of this connection during the Jeremy Corbyn era. The attacks and abuse following the October 7, 2023, events in Israel have further pushed some Jews towards the right, prioritizing safety over ideology.
The article further explores the complex dynamics of polarisation within British Jewish political life. David Feldman identifies two key factors: disagreements over Israel, especially among younger Jews, and debates surrounding the drivers of antisemitism. The idea that pro-Palestine movements are the primary cause of antisemitism is gaining traction, with some extreme elements suggesting that Jewish safety is inherently opposed to Palestinian wellbeing. This polarisation has led to a decline in support for the main political parties among British Jews, with a significant portion now favouring the Greens over Reform.
The piece also touches on the community's response to rising hostility towards immigrants. Alan Mendoza's controversial post about 'alien values' and the removal of those subscribing to 'alien religious ideologies' reflects a growing unease within the community. Rabbi David Mason highlights the historical connection between Jewish solidarity with migrants and minority communities, but warns of a potential fraying of this bond as fear and suspicion grow.
Despite these challenges, the Jewish community continues to strive for unity and allyship. The Jewish Leadership Council and the Board of Deputies are praised for their efforts to bring different sections of the community together. However, the article concludes by cautioning against the dangers of aligning too closely with the right, as some Jews gravitate towards far-right figures like Tommy Robinson. The Jewish left must navigate this complex terrain, finding common ground while maintaining its core values of inclusion and solidarity.
